Bungwe Loona za Misonkho, Zotuluka ndi Misonkho ya Utumiki, ku Hyderabad (CESTAT Hyderabad) lakana lamulo loti feteleza wa bio-fertilizer wotumizidwa ndi Jasmine Biotechnology aikidwenso m'gulu la mankhwala ophera tizilombo.

Bungwe la Customs, Excise and Service Taxes (CESTAT), ku Hyderabad, posachedwapa lasintha chisankho chake chosintha zinthu za Jasmine Biotechnologies zomwe zimatumizidwa kuchokera kunja.feteleza wachilengedwe ku mankhwala ophera tizilombo.
Khotilo linagamula kuti akuluakulu a kasitomu analephera kupereka umboni wokhutiritsa, wodalirika komanso wovomerezeka mwalamulo wosonyeza kuti zinthuzo zinali mankhwala ophera tizilombo kapena katundu woletsedwa.
Khothi lopangidwa ndi Commissioner wa Judicial Commissioner Angad Prasad ndi Technical Commissioner Ak Choteesh lavomereza ma apilo anayi okhudzana ndi lamulo la Appellate Commissioner, Hyderabad.

Mkanganowu ukukhudza zinthu zomwe zatumizidwa kunja zomwe zalengezedwa kuti ndi mankhwala oteteza zomera otchedwa "Jinbo K Bio-fertilizer/Exodus", zomwe zili pansi pa msonkho wa msonkho wa msonkho nambala 3101 0099.
Bungweli linanena kuti zinthu zomwe zatumizidwa kunja zinali ndi matrine ndi mankhwala ena ofanana nawo. Chifukwa chake, motsatira lamulo la Pesticides Act la 1968, zinthuzi ziyenera kugawidwa m'gulu la mankhwala ophera tizilombo pansi pa Mutu 38 ndiayenera kulembetsa.
Akuluakulu a misonkho adzudzula dzikolo kuti lapereka mfundo zabodza komanso kuphwanya lamulo la Pesticides Act potengera malipoti a labotale ochokera ku Regional Centre for Organic Farming (RCOF) ku Bangalore ndi Indian Institute of Chemical Technology (IICT) ku Hyderabad.
Katunduyu adalandidwa motsatira Gawo 111(d) ndi 111(m) la Customs Act. Zilango zinaperekedwanso motsatira Gawo 112(a) ndi 114AA.
Komabe, khotilo linapeza kusagwirizana kwakukulu m'malipoti a labotale. Khotilo linanena kuti limodzi mwa malipotiwo linanena momveka bwino kuti "zotsatira za kusanthula sizinawonetse kuchuluka kulikonse kogwirizana ndi mankhwala ophera tizilombo."

"Laboratori yokha ikangolemba kuti palibe mankhwala ophera tizilombo, dipatimentiyi singadalire mwachisawawa kupezeka kwa ma alkaloid achilengedwe kuti itsimikize kuti mankhwalawa ndi mankhwala ophera tizilombo," adatero woweruza milanduyo.
Khotilo linagamula kuti kupezeka kwa ma alkaloid achilengedwe sikutsimikizira kuti chinthu chochokera kunja ndi mankhwala ophera tizilombo.
Khotilo linanenanso kuti bungweli linalephera kupereka umboni wotsimikizira kuti zinthuzo, malingaliro a akatswiri, kapena malipoti ofufuza zamalonda atha kukhala ndi phindu pa malonda—umboni womwe ungatsimikizire kuti zinthuzo zalandiridwa ngati malonda kapena zinagulitsidwa ngati mankhwala ophera tizilombo.
Khotilo linanenanso kuti: “Dipatimenti yalephera kutsimikizira kubisa mwadala kapena zabodza. Katundu wonse wolowetsedwa kunja adalembetsedwa motsatira zilengezo zovomerezeka zolowera kunja, limodzi ndi kufotokozera kwa katunduyo ndi zikalata zochirikiza. Katunduyu sanalowe m'dzikolo mwachinsinsi.”
Khotilo linanenanso kuti kulephera kufunsa mafunso kwa olemba lipotilo kunali kuphwanya mfundo ya chilungamo chachilengedwe.
"Zilango zomwe zimaperekedwa motsatira Gawo 112(a) ndi 114AA la Customs Act n'zosavomerezeka chifukwa palibe umboni wokhudza kutenga nawo mbali mwadala ndi chinyengo, chinyengo mwadala kapena kuzemba misonkho mwadala," woweruzayo adawonjezera.
Khotilo linanena kuti bungweli lalephera kupereka umboni wokhutiritsa, wodalirika komanso wovomerezeka mwalamulo kuti lithandizire zomwe likunena ndipo motero linapeza kuti kusintha kwa zinthuzo pansi pa Customs Tariff No. 3808 9199 sikunali koyenera.
Motero, kulanda katundu, kusonkhanitsa misonkho, kulipira chindapusa, ndi zilango zomwe zinaperekedwa zinathetsedwa. Apiloyo inavomerezedwa.